Science, Technologies, Innovations №1(33) 2025, 79-93 р

http://doi.org/10.35668/2520-6524-2025-1-09

Androshchuk H. O. — PhD in Economics, Associate Professor, Chief Researcher, Scientific Research Institute of Intellectual Property of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 11, K. Malevуch Str., building 4, Kyiv, Ukraine, 03680; genandro1@gmail.com; +38 044 200-08-76; ORCID: 0000-0003-0781-9740

SECRET INVENTIONS: APPLICATION EXAMINATION PROBLEMS

Abstract. The paper examines the economic and legal problems of patent and innovation activity in the defense sector. Based on the indicators and legal framework of IP5 – the largest intellectual property offices in the world (USA, EPO, China, Japan, South Korea), the status, trends in regulation and features of the examination of applications for secret inventions and utility models (conflicting applications, secret prior art, secret use) in different jurisdictions are shown. The role of patent examination of applications for secret inventions is growing. Leading IP offices in the world, in particular IP5 countries, are responding to this by making changes to patent legislation, revising the rules for conducting the examination of applications for secret inventions using digital tools and AI. The procedure for forming the Compendium of Information Constituting a State Secret is analyzed, problematic issues in this area are identified, and proposals for Ukraine to resolve them are made. It is concluded that the procedure for forming the Summary of Information, examination of the classification of information categories as state secrets, the degree of its secrecy, and decision-making should be changed by transferring these powers to the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine on the basis of collegial review using a single methodology for determining potential harm to public interests protected by the state in the information sphere that may occur as a result of the disclosure of information or the loss of material media constituting a state secret.

Keywords: intellectual property, secret invention, patent examination, state secret.

REFERENCES

  1. (2024). World Intellectual Property Indicators Report: Global Patent Filings Reach Record High in 2023. WIPO. Geneva. Retrieved from: https://www.wipo.int/pressroom/en/articles/2024/article_0015.html?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=Search%3A+WIPI+2024+%28EN%29&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAgoq7BhBxEiwAVcW0LBBx9T4aeSPX8P5xqkISM4fhldzngzzKl3xuUaFfI7NyKWEHXXvgBBoC4nAQAvD_BwE.
  2. Worthington, R., & Sullens, T. (August, 23, 2024). Growth in military patents reveals shift to non-traditional technologies. DEFENCE ONLINE. Retrieved from: https://www.defenceonline.co.uk/2024/08/23/growth-in-military-patents-reveals-shift-to-non-traditional-technologies/.
  3. (July 1, 2024). Filings of secret ‘National Security’ patents increase 36 % in a year amid military tech developments. The Patent Lawyer. Retrieved from: https://patentlawyermagazine.com/filings-of-secret-national-security-patents-increase-36-in-a-year-amid-military-tech-developments/.
  4. Androshchuk, H. A., & Rabotiahova, L. Y. (2001). Patentnoe pravo: pravovaia okhrana yzobretenyi [Patent law: legal protection invented]. Kiev, 232 p. [in Russ.].
  5. Krainiev, P. P., Rabotiahova, L. I., & Diatlyk, I. I. (2000). Patentuvannia vynakhodiv v Ukraini [Patenting of inventions in Ukraine]. Kyiv, 340 p. [in Ukr.].
  6. Boshytskyi, Yu. L., & Voronin, Ya. H. (2010). Pravova okhorona vynakhodiv ta korysnykh modelei v Ukraini: problemy teorii ta praktyky [Legal protection of inventions and utility models in Ukraine: problems of theory and practice]. Kyiv, 339p. [in Ukr.].
  7. Boshytskyi, Yu. L., & Yasharova, M. M. (2012). Pravove rehuliuvannia sluzhbovoho vynakhidnytstva [Legal regulation of service invention]. Kyiv, 260 p. [in Ukr.].
  8. Androshchuk, H. O. (2013). Derzhavne rehuliuvannia vidnosyn u sferi sluzhbovoho vynakhidnytstva [State regulation of relations in the field of official invention]. Kyiv, 234 p. [in Ukr.].
  9. Kirin, R. S., Khomenko, V. L., & Korostashova, I. M. (2015). Patentolohiia [Patentology]. Dnipropetrovsk, 424 p. [in Ukr.].
  10. Androshchuk, H. O., & Rabotiahova, L. I. (2018). Patentni systemy zarubizhnykh krain: strukturovanyi analiz zakonodavstva [Patent systems of foreign countries: a structured analysis of legislation]. Kyiv, 213 p. [in Ukr.].
  11. Androshchuk, H.O., & Rabotiahova, L.I. (2018). Patentne pravo: mizhnarodno-pravove rehuliuvannia [Patent law: international legal regulation]. Kyiv, 286 p. [in Ukr.].
  12. Androshchuk, H.O., & Rabotiahova, L.I. (2018). Patentni systemy ta zakonodavstvo krain SND, Baltii i Hruzii [Patent systems and legislation of the CIS, Baltic and Georgian countries]. Kyiv, 320 p. [in Ukr.].
  13. Kapitsa, Yu. M., Kossko, T. H., Makhnovskyi, D. S., Khomenko, I. I., Aralova, N. I., & Turov, M. P.; Kapitsa Yu. M. (Eds.). (2021). Vynakhidnytska diialnist u naukovykh ustanovakh [Inventive activity in scientific institutions]. Kyiv, 455 p. [in Ukr.].
  14. About IP5 co-operation.fiveIPofficed. Retrieved from: https://www.fiveipoffices.org/about.
  15. Baker, A. (2020). Secret prior art: a trap for the unwary? Retrieved from: https://www.dyoung.com/en/knowledgebank/articles/secret-prior-art.
  16. Henry, M. K. (2024). What is prior art? HENRY. Retrieved from: https://henry.law/blog/what-is-prior-art/.
  17. (2023). Kerivnytstvo OESR z patentnoi statystyky [OECD Guidelines on Patent Statistics]. OECD; MON; DNTB. Kyiv, 161 p. Retrieved from: https://mon.gov.ua/static-objects/mon/sites/1/nauka/2023/11/15/01/Kerivnytstvo.OESR.z.patentnoyi.statystyky.15.11.2023.pdf [in Ukr.].
  18. (2024). What constitutes “secret use” in patent law? BlueIron. Retrieved from: https://blueironip.com/ufaqs/what-constitutes-secret-use-in-patent-law/.
  19. Соmparative Report “Secret Prior Art” among IP5 Countries. AIGI Intellectual Property Law Firm. Retrieved from: https://en.aigipat.com/patent/articles/detail_152.html.
  20. Invention Secrecy Act. Wikipedia. Retrieved from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invention_Secrecy_Act.
  21. Spector, M., & Burke, J. (2021). The Good, the Bad and the Missing: Findings from a Review of the Data on Granted Retroactive Foreign Filing Licenses. Patent Office Exam. Retrieved from: https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2021/01/26/good-bad-missing-findings-review-data-granted-retroactive-foreign-filing-licenses/id=129348/.
  22. Sing, S. (2024). Where Are the IP5 Investing? Mapping the IP5’s Expenditure Landscape. ASTA. Retrieved from: https://www.readipwave.com/where-are-the-ip5-investing-mapping-the-ip5s-investment-landscape-2/.
  23. Androshchuk, H. O. (2024). Inozemna litsenziia na podannia zaiavky za kordonom na vynakhid, stvorenyi v Kytai [Foreign license to apply abroad for an invention created in China]. Aktualni problemy intelektualnoho, informatsiinoho, IT ta Internet prava [Current Problems of Intellectual, Information, IT and Internet Law] Collection of materials of the Eighth All-Ukrainian Scientific and Practical Conference (Lviv, May 15, 2024). Lviv, P. 8–14. [in Ukr.].
  24. Sugimura, K., & Izumi, T. (2024). Japan: AI becomes key focus as patent office streamlines prosecution processes. IAM. Retrieved from: https://www.iam-media.com/review/the-patent-prosecution-review/2025/article/japan-ai-becomes-key-focus-patent-office-streamlines-prosecution-processes.
  25. (2021). Patent Examination Guidelines January. Korean Intellectual Property Office. Retrieved from: https://www.kipo.go.kr/upload/en/download/Patent_Examination_Guidelines_2021.pdf.
  26. (2019). O sekretnyh izobreteniyah: Zakon Respubliki Tadzhikistan ot 02.01.2019 g. № 1569 [On secret inventions: Law of the Republic of Tajikistan dated 02.01.2019 No. 1569]. Retrieved from: http://www.portali-huquqi.tj/publicadliya/view_qonunhoview.php?showdetail=&asosi_id=12041. [in Russ.].
  27. (2006). O sekretnyh izobreteniyah: Zakon Kyrgyzskoj Respubliki ot 17 marta 2006 goda №79 [On secret inventions: Law of the Kyrgyz Republic of March 17, 2006 No. 79]. Retrieved from: https://wipolex-resources-eu-central-1-358922420655.s3.amazonaws.com/edocs/lexdocs/laws/ru/kg/kg298ru_1.pdf [in Russ.].
  28. (2005). Pro zatverdzhennia Zvodu vidomostei, shcho stanovliat derzhavnu taiemnytsiu: Nakaz SBU vid 12.08.2005 № 440 [Pro zatverdzhennia Zvodu vidomostei, shcho stanovliat derzhavnu taiemnytsiu: Nakaz SBU vid 12.08.2005 No. 440]. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0902-05#Text [in Ukr.].
  29. Semeniuk, O. (2016). Poriadok vidnesennia informatsii do derzhavnoi taiemnytsi: porivnialnyi analiz vitchyznianoho ta zarubizhnoho zakonodavstva, shliakhy udoskonalennia tsiiei protsedury [The procedure for submitting information to the state prison: a regular analysis of domestic and foreign legislation, ways to streamline this procedure]. Yurydychna Ukraina [Legal Ukraine]. 3–4, 58–64. Retrieved from: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/urykr_2016_3-4_11 [in Ukr.].
  30. (2024). Pro zatverdzhennia Pravyl skladannia, podannia ta provedennia ekspertyzy zaiavky na vynakhid i zaiavky na korysnu model : Nakaz Ministerstva ekonomiky 09.09.2024 № 23301 [About the approval of the Rules for the formation, submission and examination of applications for wines and applications for the corrisna model: Order of the Ministry of Economy 09.09.2024 No. 23301]. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z1411-24#Text [in Ukr.].
  31. Androshchuk, H. O. (2020). Instytut sekretnykh vynakhodiv yak faktor zabezpechennia natsionalnoi bezpeky [The Institute of Secret Inventions as a Factor in Ensuring National Security]. Nauka ta naukoznavstvo [Science and scientific studies]. 4 (110), 24–43. DOI: https://doi. org/10.15407/sofs2020.04.024 [in Ukr.].
  32. (2016). Rekomendatsii slukhan u Komiteti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy z pytan nauky i osvity: “Zakonodavche zabezpechennia rozvytku Natsionalnoi innovatsiinoi systemy: stan ta shliakhy vyrishennia” (15 chervnia 2016 r.) [Recommendations of the hearings in the Committee of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on Science and Education: “Legislative Support for the Development of the National Innovation System: Status and Solutions” (June 15, 2016)]. Retrieved from: https://kno.rada.gov.ua/news/Robota_Kom/Zasid_Kom/Rish_Kom/VIII_skl/4_sesiya/74708.html [in Ukr.].
  33. Kossko, T. H. Naukovi vidkryttia vchenykh Natsionalnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy v 60–80-kh rr. KhKh storichchia [Scientific discoveries of scientists of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine in the 60s–80s of the 20th century]. 15p. Retrieved from: https://inb.dnsgb.com.ua/2018-2/12.pdf [in Ukr.].
  34. Androshuk, G. A., Boshickij, Yu. L., & Bulat, E. A. et al. (2004). Nauchnye otkrytiya uchenyh Ukrainy [Scientific discoveries of Ukrainian scientists]. Kiev, 111p. [in Russ.].
  35. Smyrnov, V. (2011). Viktor Tymofiiovych Hrinchenko [Viktor Tymofiiovych Hrinchenko]. Poltava istorychna [Poltava istorychna]. Retrieved from: http://poltavahistory.inf.ua/mans2_9u.html.
  36. Korchenko, O. H., Arkhypov, O. Ie., & Dreis, Yu. O. (2014). Otsiniuvannia shkody natsionalnii bezpetsi Ukrainy u razi vytoku derzhavnoi taiemnytsi [Assessment of damage to the national security of Ukraine in the event of a leak of state secrets]. Kyiv, 332p. Retrieved from: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/286628674.pdf [in Ukr.].